Pair your culinary adventure with one of our Anna Maria Island pet-friendly rentals, and prepare for a vacation with your furry friend in mind!
Whether you are seeking a beachfront brunch, a seafood feast, or a cozy cafe experience, you’ll find the perfect place to share a meal and create lasting memories in some of the best restaurants.
Harry’s Grill
With its culinary haven offering a distinctive dining experience, Harry’s Grill perfectly complements the island’s serene beauty. From fresh seafood to mouthwatering steaks, the chefs draw inspiration from traditional and contemporary recipes, resulting in a harmonious fusion of flavors that never fails to impress. Signature dishes include flavorful crab cakes, the renowned Island Catch, exquisitely grilled fish paired with locally sourced vegetables, and expertly seasoned ribeye steak. Their commitment to quality and taste ensures a dining experience that is nothing short of exceptional. They treat all guests like family, ensuring your dining experience is truly unforgettable; they frequently have live entertainment, and their outside patio welcomes your animal companions.
The combination of delectable food, enchanting music, and Anna Maria Island’s natural beauty creates an unforgettable dining experience. Harry’s Grill is one of Anna Maria Island’s restaurants transcending the traditional restaurant experience; it’s a culinary paradise where superb dishes, heartfelt hospitality, and an enchanting ambiance converge to create lasting memories. Whether you’re a passionate food enthusiast, a family seeking a cozy dinner spot, or a couple looking for a romantic evening by the beach, Harry’s Grill promises to leave a lasting impression on your taste buds and heart.
Skinny’s
With its relaxed ambiance, this restaurant is a beloved destination for locals and visitors searching for a delightful dining experience. From the moment you step inside, Skinny’s surprises diners with its diverse menu, flavorful dishes, and an inviting atmosphere that instantly puts you at ease. The casual setting encourages guests to unwind, making it an ideal spot for families, solo travelers, and anyone seeking a laid-back yet exceptional dining experience where pets are welcome.
The eclectic menu caters to various tastes and dietary preferences, featuring mouthwatering dishes such as the renowned seafood ceviche, the signature Skinny Burger, and the compelling quinoa-stuffed bell pepper. The craft drinks and happy hour offer a perfect beverage selection to complement your meal and provide a refreshing break after a day of exploring Anna Maria Island. Skinny’s is an absolute must-visit destination for food enthusiasts and island explorers. They take great pride in offering unique and memorable dining where flavorful dishes, diverse options, and warm hospitality create an unforgettable culinary journey.
Duffy’s
Discover Duffy’s, a true culinary treasure that captures the essence of coastal charm and culinary excellence on Anna Maria Island. With its idyllic setting, diverse menu, and warm hospitality, Duffy’s promises an unforgettable dining experience that perfectly complements the island’s natural beauty. At Duffy’s, they celebrate the island’s abundant seafood and locally sourced ingredients, expertly crafting dishes that delight even the most discerning palates. The famed Florida Conch Fritters are a favorite among seafood enthusiasts, perfectly seasoned and served with a zesty dipping sauce.
For those seeking a taste of the island’s land offerings, the seared filet mignon, accompanied by a medley of locally sourced vegetables, is sure to please. They take pride in offering vegan and vegetarian guests various options, with creative dishes highlighting the island’s bountiful produce and plant-based goodness. Their culinary expertise extends to craft cocktails and a carefully curated wine list, with mixologists crafting refreshing concoctions inspired by the island’s tropical charm. The bar menu is a treasure trove of libations, boasting classic mojitos and innovative island-inspired martinis. If you find yourself on Anna Maria Island, we invite you to indulge in the culinary delights at Duffy’s. Your taste buds and heart will be grateful for the experience when you can share these moments with your canine companion.
The Waterfront
The Waterfront is an exquisite gem. Loved by locals and tourists alike, this restaurant offers a tranquil escape from the daily grind, enticing visitors with a laid-back coastal atmosphere, an open-air deck, and the gentle caress of the sea breeze, all of which combine to create an idyllic backdrop for a relaxing and unforgettable meal. The culinary delights celebrate the island’s bounty, featuring freshly caught seafood, succulent shrimp cocktails, and expertly grilled fish.
For non-seafood lovers, they proudly offer a diverse selection of equally enticing land-based dishes. One of the most cherished moments is the sunset dining experience, where the sky transforms into a vibrant canvas of oranges, pinks, and purples as the evening descends. Whether it’s a romantic date night or a casual family gathering, this awe-inspiring spectacle leaves a lasting impression on every visitor. This restaurant effortlessly blends the island’s magic with culinary delights, ensuring an unforgettable and enriching experience for all who visit, including your dog!
Plan Your Visit
As your trusted partner in creating cherished memories on this enchanting Gulf Coast gem, Lizzie Lu’s Island Retreat is the perfect choice for your dream vacation on Anna Maria Island.
The Sandbar
The Sandbar’s toes-in-the-sand dining experience creates an unforgettable atmosphere, where guests are treated to breathtaking views of the Gulf waters and the gentle sway of palm trees without having to leave their dog behind. As the day draws to a close, the restaurant transforms into a magical spot to witness the mesmerizing sunset over the Gulf of Mexico. To enhance this captivating spectacle, skilled mixologists craft delicious cocktails that perfectly complement the sunset, making it an ideal spot for a pre-dinner drink or a post-meal toast.
The warm and welcoming atmosphere invites families to enjoy relaxed lunches or dinners, fostering unforgettable moments. Environmental sustainability is of utmost importance at The Sandbar, and they are proud members of the Blue Community Consortium. The Sandbar invites you to experience a dining journey like no other on Anna Maria Island.
Bridge Street Bistro
Bridge Street Bistro is rated as one of the best restaurants on Anna Maria Island, showcasing the finest produce from the region. The menu caters to various tastes and preferences, enticing your palate with appetizers like coconut-crusted calamari and tangy ceviche, skillfully combining textures and flavors to create a compelling experience.
For the main course, seafood enthusiasts can savor Chef’s seafood pasta, while those who prefer land-based delicacies can relish tender steaks and herb-roasted chicken. Complementing your culinary journey, the extensive wine list and carefully curated craft cocktail selection add a touch of refinement to your meal. Bridge Street Bistro on Anna Maria Island celebrates the essence of this beautiful coastal destination, and every aspect of this restaurant is thoughtfully crafted to offer an unforgettable gastronomic journey. When you find yourself on Anna Maria Island, we invite you (and your pooch!) to carve out an evening to immerse yourself in the flavors and ambiance of Bridge Street Bistro.
Book Your Anna Maria Island Vacation Rental With Lizzie Lu’s!
Lizzie Lu’s Island Retreat offers a comprehensive selection of top-notch AMI vacation rentals, catering to diverse preferences and needs. With a wide variety of pet-friendly accommodations, including one to four-bedroom beachfront condos and cottages, Lizzie Lu’s Island Retreat provides excellent comfort and amenities. Our commitment to excellence extends beyond the properties, with knowledgeable staff providing local insights and recommendations. The island offers a treasure trove of natural beauty, allowing guests to enjoy leisurely walks and stunning sunsets and explore the island’s shops, restaurants, and art galleries. Booking your Anna Maria Island pet-friendly rentals confidently is easy at Lizzie Lu’s Island Retreat, as we prioritize satisfaction and safety.
