The Best Anna Maria Island Rentals with One and Two Bedrooms

Are you searching for Anna Maria Island 1 and 2 bedroom rentals? If so, then allow us to shorten your search. The following five are some of AMI’s finest, most charming 1- and 2-bedroom rentals. Keep in mind, since they’re so popular, they tend to book up fast! They all offer a wide array of modern amenities and beautiful views, but let’s take a closer look at what each one boasts.

Outside view of AMI vacation rental

Yellowfin Cottage

Located along 75th Street in Holmes Beach, Yellowfin Cottage has a cute red brick driveway and is immersed in local flora and fauna. It is just two houses away from the beach, making this ground floor half duplex perfect for beach-lovers.

There is an outdoor shower and heated pool as well as a gorgeous private patio. There are two bedrooms (a master bedroom with a king-sized mattress and a second bedroom with two twin beds) and one bathroom. Two parking spots are available, and complimentary beach chairs and a wagon come with this rental.

Note that this location is pet-friendly with a pet fee applied.

Backyard of Anna Maria Island vacation rental

Lemon Cottage

Make your way to the island with these Anna Maria directions and enjoy a stay in Lemon Cottage. You’ll be situated two blocks from the beach in this two-bedroom, two-bath ground-level half-duplex. You will be enshrined by a private patio and gorgeous tropical landscaping features. Hop into the outdoor shower after taking a swim in the heated pool, then make your way out on the town.

Lemon Cottage has its own gas grill, and both bedrooms offer a comfy king-sized bed. A washer and dryer combo are included, as is air conditioning. Oh, and dogs are totally welcome! They will love cuddling with you on one of those plush king-sized beds every night.

pool area of a 2 and 3 bedroom rental in Anna Maria Island

Flop Cottage

Flop Cottage is one of those AMI rentals that will stop you in your tracks. Just a block away from the beach, this cottage has everything you could possibly want, from a Weber grill to a chic retro-style kitchen with seating for four people. Enjoy a queen-size bed in the master bedroom and high-speed Internet to help you stay connected to friends and family while you are away.

You can access concierge services here, such as bike and beach rentals, baby item rentals, cleaning services, and GEM cars. Just bear in mind that this location does not allow pets and is a one-bedroom rental, making more ideal for couples or a couple of best friends traveling together.

backyard area of Anna Maria Island rental

Groovy Gecko Cottage

In terms of AMI vacation rentals, Groovy Gecko Cottage is one of the most vibrant with its retro exterior design. It is a short walk away from Holmes Beach and features two bedrooms and one and a half bathrooms. The kitchen has a bar with seating for four, and the living room is equipped with cozy furniture and cable TV. The master bedroom has a cushy king-sized bed while the second bedroom is outfitted with a queen and a twin bed, making it perfect for those traveling with children.

With an additional fee, you can bring your beloved pet along and let them enjoy the amenities too. With 950 square feet, there should be plenty of space for everyone to relax after a long day of exploring AMI.

Plan Your Trip

Anna Maria Island is an amazing vacation destination to bring the whole family to! See our Anna Maria Island vacation rentals for availability and book now.

outside bluefin cottage

Bluefin Cottage

Situated in Holmes Beach, Bluefin Cottage is a two-bed, two-bath rental with its own private patio, heated pool, and outdoor shower. The interior is spacious and has TVs in every bedroom! Dogs are welcome, and, of course, kids are too. There is a Bluetooth speaker set up, as is wireless Internet access.

You can bring up to two vehicles and park them in the huge garage or store your bikes and beach wagon in there. GEM cars are offered as part of the concierge services, as are bikes and other rental equipment. With a whopping 1,100 square footage available in this ground level half duplex, you will have no trouble fitting your family inside. Everyone can relax after a long day at the beach.