5 Best Sweet Treats on Anna Maria Island

If you’re searching for some of the most delicious, decadent and indulgent Anna Maria Island dessert options, you are in the right place, as the 5 top sweet treats listed on this page are sure to satisfy your taste buds. Grab a delectable dessert after dinner at an Anna Maria Island restaurant or a day at the beach at any of these top-rated dessert shops on the island.

#1 – The Donut Experiment

The Donut Experiment is one of the most popular Anna Maria Island dessert shops, offering some of the freshest and addicting donuts that you’ll find anywhere. You can fully customize your donut to your preferences with a wide range of toppings to choose from, along with a selection of rotating specialty donuts. This Anna Maria Island dessert shop has turned into a rapidly growing franchise in the Bradenton/Sarasota area and is a must-visit for the unique experience. Stop by the Donut Experiment at 210C Pine Avenue, Anna Maria.

#2 – Holy Cow Ice Cream Shop

The Holy Cow Ice Cream Shop is located in Holmes Beach and offers several distinct and extraordinary ice cream flavors to test out. This ice cream shop is known for its large portions and amazing flavors and textures. You can choose up to 3 flavors or more even with the smallest serving of ice cream, and there are sugar-free as well as low-fat ice cream options. Some of the popular flavors here include the salted caramel, cheesecake, hot fudge sundae, and caramel sundae, but there are many more! Stop by after a day in the sun at nearby Manatee Public Beach. You’ll find Holy Cow Ice Cream Shop at 3234 E Bay Dr. Holmes Beach, FL.

woman eating ice cream on anna maria island
Photo from Shutterstock

#3 – Two Scoops

Two Scoops offers delicious homemade ice cream at a convenient spot in the city of Anna Maria. Although it can also be crowded on warm days, you’ll find friendly and prompt service here and reasonable prices for ice cream, along with other goodies you wouldn’t expect. This ice cream shop is known for its 32 amazing flavors and unique ice cream combinations. Some of the popular desserts here include sundae, shakes, banana splits, and cookies, but you can also order food! Grab a bagel, chili dog, sandwich or order from the breakfast menu paired with a cup of coffee. Located at 101 S. Bay Blvd. and open from 9 a.m. – 10 p.m. – 7 days a week!

#4 – Hometown Desserts

Hometown Desserts in the City of Anna Maria features a wide selection of freshly baked desserts including scones, cakes, cookies, mini cupcakes, cheesecakes, fudge, pies and more. This is the ideal place to purchase delicious custom made birthday, anniversary or other special event cake if you happen to be celebrating during your trip. The coconut, key lime, citrus, orange, lemon and carrot cake are just a few of their popular specialties, but they bake their whole menu to perfection. They are also well known for their refreshing iced coffee, so be sure to stop by for a freshly made sweet treat! Located at 507 Pine Ave in the city of Anna Maria.

#5 – Joe’s Eats and Sweets

Joe’s Eats and Sweets is a top choice for sundaes and refreshing homemade ice cream with flavors that you won’t find elsewhere. Located in Bradenton Beach, this Anna Maria Island dessert shop is an ideal place to visit after enjoying the waves and sun at nearby Coquina Beach. Although the line can be long on some days, it is well worth the wait. There are a number of sugar-free ice cream options for diabetics as well as lactose-free ice cream choices. You’ll also find a nice lunch menu with pizza, burgers and other appetizing options. Joe’s Eats and Sweets is located at 219 Gulf Drive S., Bradenton Beach.

Many of these popular Anna Maria Island dessert shops are located near our pet-friendly vacation rentals, so feel free to contact us at (941)-782-8152 for directions or more information!